Post by KC on May 8, 2010 0:38:50 GMT -5
Might as well get this debate going while the finale stuff is being worked out.
But for my lovely staff that have been watching along with me, who do you feel deserves to be All-Stars? Please try to leave all personal bias out of this thread. Keep in mind that Parvati and Ben are both already in AllStars so they cannot be chosen this time.
Personally I think the final five is just fine. The only real contenders outside of the final five would be Heidi and Natalie. Maybe Colby if he lasted till merge. Jessica, Kenny, and Todd, I don't think should even be debated. People can go on about them not having the best strategy, but honestly, who else did? This was not a strategy orientated game at all. Galu Part II had no excuse in letting them get to the final three and just for that, they deserve their placing and AllStars methinks.
I think JT should have it. Aside from his vacation, he was pretty active and had great reads in his Diary Rooms. He also IMed me frequently to tell me stuff as it was going (Which I do like. A lot of people think it bothers me cause I don't say much back. But I can't say much back without influencing
). One of the most underrated players for sure, though.
Last spot is up in the air. I'm leaning towards Judd between the three top contenders not only because of his placing but because he put on much more of a fight when his ass was on the line. You can argue that Natalie and Heidi were blindsided because of the idols, but both of those weeks had dreadful planning from everyone. I dunno.
Discuss
But for my lovely staff that have been watching along with me, who do you feel deserves to be All-Stars? Please try to leave all personal bias out of this thread. Keep in mind that Parvati and Ben are both already in AllStars so they cannot be chosen this time.
Personally I think the final five is just fine. The only real contenders outside of the final five would be Heidi and Natalie. Maybe Colby if he lasted till merge. Jessica, Kenny, and Todd, I don't think should even be debated. People can go on about them not having the best strategy, but honestly, who else did? This was not a strategy orientated game at all. Galu Part II had no excuse in letting them get to the final three and just for that, they deserve their placing and AllStars methinks.
I think JT should have it. Aside from his vacation, he was pretty active and had great reads in his Diary Rooms. He also IMed me frequently to tell me stuff as it was going (Which I do like. A lot of people think it bothers me cause I don't say much back. But I can't say much back without influencing
). One of the most underrated players for sure, though.Last spot is up in the air. I'm leaning towards Judd between the three top contenders not only because of his placing but because he put on much more of a fight when his ass was on the line. You can argue that Natalie and Heidi were blindsided because of the idols, but both of those weeks had dreadful planning from everyone. I dunno.
Discuss
jk. i agree that the final 5 should be the five allstars
